Kaitlyn attended Framingham High School, where she was a three sport athlete in soccer, ice hockey and lacrosse. She was a freshman during the Flyer’s 2010 State Championship, and went on to be a captain her senior year in all three sports. Kaitlyn was also a league all-star in field hockey and ice hockey her senior year.

Kaitlyn was recruited to play both field hockey and lacrosse at Plymouth State. In field hockey she started 66 of 69 games, and finished her career with 43 goals and 16 assists. As an attacker on the lacrosse team she started 48 of 62 games, and ended her career with 83 goals, 25 assists and 40 ground balls. Kaitlyn helped lead Plymouth State to LEC Championships and an NCAA DIII berth in both 2014 and 2017. She graduated in 2017 with a degree in Elementary Education.

Kaitlyn currently works in the Holliston School District, and is an assistant coach for KP varsity girls lacrosse. In 2022, she was also named the head varsity field hockey coach at KP.